[I apologize in advance: This is a long one. And kind of sappy.]
Yesterday, I turned 30. I plan to devote an entire blog post to this milestone, but in the meantime, I’ve been thinking about my family.
Birthdays will do that to you, I suppose. Especially if you’re used to getting a phone call from a family member on your birthday, and this year you didn’t get it, because you may or may not be speaking to her, due to something you may or may not still be mad about.
My mom’s side of the family, which I was very close to at one point in time, has undergone some, how shall we phrase it, major upheavals over the last year and a half. It, well, it hasn’t been pretty.
Though I didn’t get the phone call I’d come to expect, I did get an unexpected and thoughtful gift from another family member, a gift that reminded me that no matter what crazy shit they stir up, no matter how much they hurt or disappoint you, family is for life. It may start and stop and ebb and flow, but ultimately, it’s not going anywhere. This is, of course, both a good and a bad thing.
After receiving the gift, I felt so nostalgic and thrown and touched that I dug up something I wrote about the subject five years ago. It’s a little rough around the edges, but, amazingly, it still holds some truth.
Because I’m now officially old, and old people like to reflect on the past, I’m posting my 2004 scribblings below.
*****
The Simplest, Most Complicated Relationships in the World
My mom and I haven’t been speaking to each other a whole lot lately.
I’m holding a grudge. She’s giving me my “space.” Though neither of us would admit to the other that this is what we’re doing, this is what we’re doing.
Funny how, even though we’ve know each other my whole life, even though she birthed me and named me and raised me and instilled values in me, even though we’ve seen each other at our worst and our best and naked, slapped each other, comforted each other, cried together, rejoiced together, we still have yet to find a way to effectively communicate.
“Couldn’t you tell your mom why you’re upset with her?” a friend asked me.
“What would be the point?” I said. “I would tell her how I felt, she’d feel hurt and defensive, twist it around and chalk it up to ‘Julie just being dramatic again,’ and then she’d say something like, ‘Well I guess I’m just the worst mother in the world,’ making me feel like an asshole, when, really, she’s the one being the asshole!” [In retrospect, we were both being assholes.]
In other words, telling her that she hurt me or that I’m mad at her for hurting me would get us nowhere. Because, as I’m quickly learning, family doesn’t change, and our relationships with our family members stay the same, no matter what we do or say to try to change them. Big brothers will always not take us seriously, even when we’re married and old enough to be having kids of our own. Big sisters will always have an opinion about our lives and feel the need to vocalize it. Little brothers will always call us in need of advice. Little sisters will always have a hard time accepting our significant others. And parents will always find ways to offend us, hurt us or generally piss us off.
When I think about my family, I’m a hamster, going round and round on my little treadmill, getting nowhere faster and faster. It’s tiring. Exhausting, really.
This hamster, therefore, would prefer to just stay still.
Unfortunately, staying still just makes that gulf between us, that inability to communicate, deepen and widen and deepen some more.
There are days when I think: Why not try? Why not just call her and tell her why I’m upset and break down and let her make everything okay, the way moms are supposed to do. The way she always has, until now.
But then the daughter in me kicks in, the daughter that, again, will never change, and I think: No. She should call me. Ask me what I need from her. Tell me that she’s sorry and sad that I’m hurting.
And the fact that she hasn’t done this only makes me madder, makes the grudge last, the gulf deepen, me sadder.
The thing about family, though, is that despite the fact that nothing ever changes, despite the fact that we’ve been trying to make change happen for just about as long as we’ve been alive, we never seem to stop wanting it. Hoping for it. Trying.
When I got home late last night, after a long and somewhat crappy, gloomy day, my stomach in knots, the message light on my answering machine was blinking.
I pressed play.
“Hi, honey, it’s Mom. I’m leaving the gym now and am on my way to meet Ruth for a quick bite,” she said, or rather, yelled into the speakerphone in her car. “But I wanted to call you, because I miss you, and I was thinking about you. I’ve also noticed that all the new spring lines are out right now, with some really pretty spring colors. And I thought about how pretty you are, and how you’d look really good in some of the outfits I’ve seen. So I want you to use my credit card and buy yourself two or three new outfits, okay? Because you deserve them, and will look so pretty in them. Okay? Call me back or e-mail me at work tomorrow. I love you, honey. Bye.”
The message ended, and I was torn: laugh or cry? I opted for a little of both.
Sometimes, no matter what you do or say, nothing changes, and it makes you cry. It makes you mad. It makes you want to scream. But then, other times, no matter what you do or say, nothing changes; nothing changes, and the fact that nothing changes is so touching, so heartbreaking, it makes you cry. It makes you want to sing.